Interim decree (Article 35-ter(2) of Legislative Decree 25/2008) · R.G. 6570/2026
Unofficial translation of the SOS Patto summary. The original decision or document is available in Italian only.
Headnote
Free legal counselling is a subjective right recognised by Articles 8(2)(d), 15 and 16 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 through provisions that are immediately binding. Since the determination of the special procedure must follow the lodging of the application (Articles 28 and 42(1)(a) of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348), where the file does not show that the applicant was informed of that right at the time of registration, or that he or she was already assisted by a lawyer, the accelerated border procedure applied under Articles 42(1)(j) and 45(1) is irregular, even where the breach stems from a general failure to implement the Regulation. The breach is not a mere omission of information that can be remedied in court: the procedure is converted from Article 35-ter to Article 35-bis of Legislative Decree 25/2008 and the appeal automatically suspends the decision.
The Tribunal of Catanzaro (judge Stefano Costarella) converts the procedure from Article 35-ter to Article 35-bis of Legislative Decree 25/2008 and declares automatically suspended the rejection by the Commissione territoriale of Crotone, adopted in the mandatory accelerated procedure at the border against a Bangladeshi applicant who disembarked after a search and rescue operation. The Commission had rejected the application for international protection and transmitted the file to the Questore for special protection.
The reasoning takes up, largely verbatim, that of Trib. Bologna 15398/2026: Articles 8(2)(d), 15 and 16 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 establish a subjective right to free legal counselling that is effective, individual and independent of the determining authority, which in Italy “admits of no exception, save the obvious case in which the person already has a lawyer”. Since the choice of the special procedure must follow the lodging of the application (Article 28 and Article 42(1)(a)), without a counsellor that choice does not rest on a fully substantiated application. The breach cannot be treated as a mere information obligation that can be remedied at the judicial stage, and it is not for the appellant to allege specific prejudice.
What is new is the scope of application: the Bologna decree concerned an accelerated procedure under Article 42 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348; here the principle is applied to the mandatory border procedure of Articles 43 and 45(1), based on the 20% threshold (Article 42(1)(j)).
The judge notes that neither the file nor the Commission's decision documents the information on legal counselling at the time of registration, and draws from the power of attorney an argument that there was no lawyer in the administrative phase: it was issued after the notification of the rejection, and the administration, which did not enter an appearance, never alleged otherwise.
Recalling the principle of Cass., Joint Chambers (Sezioni Unite), no. 11399/2024, understood as a general rule on the effectiveness of judicial protection, the decree removes the effects of the special procedure already at the interim stage: it applies Article 35-bis(3) of Legislative Decree 25/2008 and, the exception of Article 68(3)(a) of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 having fallen away, declares the decision suspended for the entire duration of the proceedings.
This is the second published decision to base the re-expansion of the right to remain on the lack of legal counselling alone, and the first in a border procedure; in Trib. Firenze 13481/2026 the same defect combined with the falling away of the 20% threshold. To the opposite effect, Trib. Venezia 14909/2026 requires that the appeal indicate the defence right actually precluded. On the same Commission of Crotone, for a different defect, see Trib. Catanzaro 5971/2026.
Related provisions