← All case law

Interim decree (Article 35-bis(4) of Legislative Decree 25/2008) · R.G. 13533/2026

Tribunal of Brescia, 16 November 2026

Ordinary procedure restored · automatic suspension

Unofficial translation of the SOS Patto summary. The original decision or document is available in Italian only.

Headnote

Article 79(3) of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348, which applies the Regulation to applications lodged from 12 June 2026, produces improper retroactive effects and must be interpreted in accordance with the principle of proportionality (Article 5 TEU) and the principles of legal certainty and protection of legitimate expectations: it cannot extend to applications whose wish was expressed while Directive 2013/32/EU was in force and which were not lodged within the time limits then laid down by Article 26(2) and (2-bis) of Legislative Decree 25/2008. The issue, upon the drawing up of the C3, of the residence permit referring to Article 22 of Legislative Decree 142/2015 in the text prior to Decree-Law 100/2026 confirms that the administration itself regarded the former rules as applicable. If the accelerated procedure did not comply with its time limits, the appeal automatically suspends the decision (Cass., SS.UU., no. 11399/2024).

The Tribunale di Brescia (judge Dr Christian Colombo) declared automatically suspended the enforceability of the decision by which the Commissione territoriale of Brescia, on 23 September 2026, had decided the application in the accelerated procedure under Article 42 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348. The applicant had expressed the wish to apply for protection to the Questura on 2 April 2026; the Questura had set the fingerprinting for 29 June and the C3 form was drawn up only on 6 August 2026.

The conduct of the administration

The first argument is documentary. Upon the drawing up of the C3, a provisional residence permit was issued that refers to Article 22 of Legislative Decree 142/2015 in the wording prior to Decree-Law 100/2026 (work permitted after sixty days from issue). For the Tribunal it follows that the Ministry of the Interior regarded the former rules as applicable, so that the subsequent choice of the accelerated procedure of Article 42 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 contradicts the initial conduct and the legitimate expectations it generated in the applicant.

Article 79 and legitimate expectations

The second argument concerns Article 79(3) of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348. The decree acknowledges that the provision links the application of the Regulation to applications "lodged" from 12 June 2026, but holds that it produces "improper" retroactive effects. Referring to the case-law of the Court of Justice (Cases C-181/20, C-67/09 and C-368/89), it reads the provision in accordance with the principle of proportionality (Article 5 TEU) and the principles of legal certainty and protection of legitimate expectations. The Regulation, therefore, does not extend to applications whose wish was expressed while Directive 2013/32/EU was in force and which were not lodged within the time limits of Article 26(2) and (2-bis) of Legislative Decree 25/2008 (three working days, extendable by ten).

The procedural outcome

Once the former rules are applied, the judge finds that the time limits of the accelerated procedure were not complied with and, according to Cass., SS.UU., no. 11399/2024, the derogation from automatic suspension operates only if the accelerated procedure was followed in each of its stages. The operative part declares the enforceability suspended by operation of law and, as a consequence, inadmissible the alternative requests for suspension and for authorisation to remain.

Placement

It converges with the line of authority that anchors the regime to the expression of the wish (Trib. Bologna 13590/2026, Trib. Messina 2614/2026, Trib. Torino 17608/2026), and runs contrary to Trib. Perugia 3148/2026. What is distinctive is the foundation: not the interpretation of the notion of "lodging", but legitimate expectations, reinforced by the conduct of the administration itself.

📄 Download the decision (PDF, in Italian)