← All case law

Interim decree (Article 35-bis(4) of Legislative Decree 25/2008) · N.R.G. 15398-1/2026

Tribunal of Bologna, 3 November 2026

Ordinary procedure restored · automatic suspension

Unofficial translation of the SOS Patto summary. The original decision or document is available in Italian only.

Headnote

Free legal counselling is a subjective right of the applicant, recognised by Articles 8(2)(d), 15 and 16 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 through provisions that are immediately binding, of which the Member States regulate only the arrangements; in Italy it admits of no exceptions, unless the applicant already has a lawyer. Since the determination of the accelerated examination procedure must follow the lodging of the application (Articles 28 and 42(1)(a)), the failure to inform the applicant of that right and the failure to offer a counsellor render the special procedure irregular, even where they stem from a general failure to implement the Regulation. The court verifies the right to remain under Article 68 ex officio and, once the irregularity is established, declares it.

The Tribunal of Bologna (judge Marco Gattuso) establishes the right to remain of a Pakistani applicant, who entered Italy on 1 July 2026 and whose application had been rejected as manifestly unfounded in the accelerated examination procedure under Article 42 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348. By an investigative order of 2 October 2026 the judge had asked the Commission for proof of the information on legal counselling and of the counsellor offered. Once the time limit expired, the Commission had filed nothing.

Ex officio verification of the right to remain

The decree begins by stating that the regularity of the administrative procedure is verified ex officio, on the basis of Cass., Joint Chambers, No. 11399/2024 and of the judgment of the Court of Justice in Alace and Canpelli. Article 68 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 provides for an automatic suspensive effect of the appeal, to which there corresponds a subjective right to remain; a party's request is needed only for the authorisation to remain under paragraph 4. The judge must therefore declare the right to remain where it is disputed, even if the party has requested only the authorisation.

Legal counselling as a subjective right

Articles 8(2)(d), 15 and 16 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 recognise a right to free, effective and individual legal counselling, provided by a counsellor independent of the determining authority. The only exception transposed in Italy is that of the applicant already assisted by a lawyer. The right is tied to the lodging of the application (Article 28) and the accelerated examination procedure must follow it, because Article 42(1)(a) looks at the facts set out by the applicant “when lodging the application”. Without a counsellor, the choice of the special procedure does not rest on a fully substantiated application.

The consequence for the accelerated examination procedure

The judge rules out that this is a mere breach of information obligations, capable of being remedied at the judicial stage: it is an infringement of the right of defence in the administrative phase, which vitiates the decision. It is not for the applicant to allege specific prejudice. Having noted that no Italian implementing act has given effect to Articles 8, 15 and 16 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348, the decree concludes that the breach, “even as a consequence of a general failure to implement, inevitably leads to an irregularity of the individual procedures”. The operative part establishes the right to remain and the right to the immediate issue of the documentation.

This is the first published decision to base the re-expansion of the right to remain solely on the lack of legal counselling. In Trib. Bologna 11342/2026 the same defect was combined with others, and the notion of lodging the application is developed in Trib. Bologna 13060/2026.

📄 Download the decision (PDF, in Italian)