← All case law

Twin interim decrees (Article 35-bis(4) of Legislative Decree 25/2008) · R.G. 17994/2026 e 18044/2026

Tribunal of Turin, 28 October 2026

Ordinary procedure restored · automatic suspension

Unofficial translation of the SOS Patto summary. The original decision or document is available in Italian only.

Headnote

Where, in the course of the proceedings, interviews with an anti-trafficking organisation bring to light elements attributable prima facie to trafficking for the purpose of labour exploitation, concerning facts already mentioned by the applicant at the screening stage but not explored before the Commissione territoriale, the applicant's individual situation distinguishes him from the generality of persons on whom the recognition rate is based: the condition of Article 42(1), point (j), of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 falls away and, with it, the mandatory border procedure, which requires the conditions of Article 43 together with one of the cases of Article 42(1). Since Article 53(2), point (a), requires the border procedure to end “at any stage”, the application returns to the ordinary procedure and the appeal has automatic suspensive effect under Article 68(1).

By two twin decrees of 28 October 2026 the Tribunal of Turin (judge Alessandra Aragno) finds that the conditions of the mandatory border procedure applied by the Commissione territoriale are not met, declares the automatic suspensive effect of the appeals and orders the issue of the document provided for by Article 4(4) of Legislative Decree 142/2015.

The vulnerability that emerged in the proceedings

In both cases the applicant had already reported, at the screening stage, violence and torture suffered in Libya. In the course of the proceedings the defence arranged for him to be taken in charge by an anti-trafficking organisation, and the first interview brought out a picture (an intermediary for the departure, documents confiscated on arrival in Libya, labour exploitation, ill-treatment and, in one case, sale to several employers and kidnapping for ransom) which the Tribunal considers “comparable, prima facie, to labour trafficking and, in any event, giving rise to a high degree of vulnerability”. These are matters the applicant had already mentioned but which were “not explored in depth” before the Commissione territoriale.

From the 20% threshold to the ordinary procedure

The decisive step concerns Article 42(1), point (j), of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348. The Tribunal reads it in an individual perspective: what the organisation reported makes the absence of the condition plain, because “the individual situation of the appellant distinguishes him from the generality of persons” on whom the percentage is based. Once the case of Article 42 falls away, so does the mandatory border procedure, which requires the conditions of Article 43 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 together with one of the cases of Article 42(1).

The moment at which the vulnerability emerges does not matter. Referring to Trib. Florence 13520/2026, the decree recalls that, if indicators emerge in the course of the procedure, the authority must re-examine the situation, as required by Article 53(2), point (a), of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348, which provides for the border procedure to end “at any stage”. The application therefore returns to the ordinary procedure, with the derogation from the right to remain falling away: the operative part declares the automatic suspensive effect under Article 68(1) and records the right to remain until the proceedings are concluded. The Tribunal also orders the free examination of the applicant and the continuation of the interviews with the anti-trafficking organisation.

Context

The decrees belong to the line of cases on unassessed trafficking indicators, alongside Trib. Florence 13509/2026 and Trib. Turin 18357/2026, where the vulnerability was already apparent from the screening. Here the new element is that the proof of vulnerability is formed in the proceedings, on the defence's initiative, and is enough on its own to rule out the special procedure. The decrees do not rule on the information obligations or on the determination.

📄 Download the decision (PDF, in Italian)